Cologeny
Being a Good Designer Doesn’t Automatically Make You a Good Creative Director
Leadership

Being a Good Designer Doesn’t Automatically Make You a Good Creative Director

If you say you want to become a creative director, why should you be one?

Opeyemi Adeyeye
Founder & Creative Director

There are a thousand reasons why a good designer aims to be a creative director someday or in the near future. You may desire more influence over the work that comes your way, You may enjoy developing ideas, and its known to man that you have a good eye, maybe people already come to you when a design needs fixing. Creative direction just feels like the sensible next step now or soon enough.

I understand that and that is valid. But all that won't make you a Creative director, at least not automatically.

Before the end of what i'm about to tell you, you'll know what will, but before then let's look at what your working day would actually look like as a creative director.

Your first responsibility is leading your team. Notice i didnt say "the". That's ownership.
Now just because you are excellent at design doesn't mean you may not struggle to lead your team. Those are parts of the job your portfolio may not prepare you for.

Take something as ordinary as reviewing a flyer. One of the designers on your team sends you a file, and you immediately see what needs to change. The spacing is off. The headline needs more room. You know exactly how you would fix it but the designer in you says “Send me the file. Let me quickly fix it.” I say this because i've said it before.

The temptation is real especially when a deadline is close and you can finish in ten minutes what might take your team member an hour.

But pay attention to how often you do that. If every difficult task ends with you taking over, the team will learn to wait for you. You’ll be busy, they’ll be dependent, and eventually you’ll wonder why nobody takes initiative.

Before you reach for the file, try explaining what you see. Give the designer a chance to work through it. You may need to spend more time on the conversation today, but that conversation will save you from fixing the same problem next week.

If you ask me and other creative directors, that is time well spent.

I’d also encourage you to get better at explaining the work before anyone starts designing. It sounds obvious until you are managing a project and realize that three of your creatives have spent two days answering three different versions of the brief.

Imagine asking your team to make a brand feel “more premium.” One designer blackifies the whole thing. Another introduces gold and a serif typeface. A third produces something that looks like a perfume advert.

They have all responded to what you said but in different directions. This happens because the team members are not aligned.

Before you send people away to explore, talk about the audience, the business, and what the work needs to communicate. Show references, but explain why you chose them. Otherwise, someone may copy the colours when what interested you was the restraint in the layout.

People cannot work confidently with information you have kept in your head.

The same care needs to carry into your feedback. “I don’t like it” tells a designer how you feel. They still need to understand what to do with that feeling.

If the message is getting lost, point out where. If the visual direction is wrong for the audience, explain the mismatch. Be specific enough that they can return to the work with a useful problem to solve.

And please, be willing to question your own reaction.

Sometimes a design will bother you because it is weak and sometimes it will be because you would have done it differently. You need to learn the difference. A team that has to reproduce your preferences on every project will eventually stop offering much else.

I’d want you to get comfortable with someone bringing an idea that improves on yours. Give it room. Ask how they arrived at it. Let them see that good thinking carries weight, even when it challenges something you suggested.

That takes some security, especially when you feel pressure to prove that you deserve to lead. You don’t have to supply the winning idea in every meeting.

Client conversations will test you too.

Suppose a client says a campaign needs “more energy.” Before you forward that comment to the team, find out what they mean. Are they talking about the headline, the colours, the imagery? Ask them to point to the part that feels wrong.

A short conversation could prevent two days of unnecessary revisions. As the one directing the work, you should care about that.

You should also care about what happens when you agree to a new request. If a client adds deliverables after approval, explain what changes. Perhaps the deadline moves. Perhaps something else comes out of scope. Work through it with them.

Its the same idea with delegation, be clear about what your team owns, who is responsible for what. Tell them which decisions they can make, where you need to be involved, and when you’ll review the work. Then give them enough room to do it.

Checking every small move will wear both of you out. Disappearing until presentation day won’t help either. Agree on review points that allow you to catch problems while there is still time to respond.

You’ll need practice with all of this. Some conversations will be awkward. You’ll give feedback that could have been clearer, step in too early, or realise you waited too long. When that happens, acknowledge your part and adjust. A title does not remove your need to learn.

I also want you to know that you are allowed to keep growing as a designer without pursuing creative direction. If what you love is the craft itself, there is plenty of serious work ahead of you. You do not owe anyone a move into management.

But if leading a team does appeal to you, start practising before the title arrives. Help someone understand a brief. Give feedback they can use. Take responsibility for a decision and stay involved long enough to see its consequences.

Over time, look at what the people working with you can do with greater confidence and less supervision. Can they explain their choices? Can they spot when an idea has drifted away from the brief? Do they feel able to disagree with you?

I’d be interested in those answers.

Your own work can show me that you’re a good designer. To understand how well you lead, I’d want to hear from the people making the work with you.

0 comments

Sign in to join the discussion.